P.J. Clarke's

July 15th, 2009 - Inaugural SBE

Location: 915 3rd Avenue, New York, NY 10022

SBE score: 91*

*the old regime, before the menu change

Burger = $8.95
The Cadillac = $11.35 (picture below)




The Results:

• Burger Patty: 9.25 [8-10 range]
• Burger Experience: 8.5 [7-10 range]
• Fries: 5.25 [4-6 range]
• Onion Rings: 8 [7-9 range]

915 3rd Ave, New York NY10022 40.759171 -73.968709

(At 55th St)

Read more: P.J. Clarke's - New York Restaurant - MenuPages American (Traditional), Bar Food Restaurant Search http://www.menupages.com/restaurants/pj-clarkes/#ixzz0co67lc08

915 3rd Ave, New York NY10022 40.759171 -73.968709

(At 55th St)

Read more: P.J. Clarke's - New York Restaurant - MenuPages American (Traditional), Bar Food Restaurant Search http://www.menupages.com/restaurants/pj-clarkes/#ixzz0co67lc08

What type of burgers do we order?

Brian: Medium-rare with american cheese (sometimes bacon)
Leila: Medium with american cheese
Luke: Medium-rare with either bleu cheese or cheddar (sometimes bacon)
Kate: Medium-rare with cheddar cheese (sometimes bacon)

How do we rate our burgers?
The score is out of 10. The scores are averaged. Highest and lowest scores are listed in the range bracket beside the average score. We additionally score the restaurant on a 0 - 100 scale which is a combination of everyone giving their own 0 - 100 score and a dynamic discussion because the final score is not a simple average.

Burger Patty: JUST the meat (quality, seasoning, cooked to order)
Burger Experience: Used to include restaurant atmosphere etc, now only the bun and everything in between

Fries and Onion Rings: seasoning, originality